How can you guys not know your own forum-nicknames. That's too funny, hehe.
What else is funny? The same discussion here as in the German forum, only in the German forum they came up with more arguments.
There are the 5 arguments against giving the defenders their points and the 4 pro-arguments summarized. I don't want to translate the whole post so you have to be satisfied with bullet-points:
"it was always like that"
"you can see who defended where that reduces gaming-depth"
"it's interesting to see where the fight took place"
"you know which accounts are vulnerable"
5 counterargument: (strongest argument)
"it encourages people to spike"
"you can't hide your multiaccounts any longer"
"it motivates most defensive players a lot"
"fairness & recognition"
"it adds depth to see which enemy account has lost their anvil / more information is always good"
That's basically it. Did I forget something relevant?