Page 3 of 11 FirstFirst 12345 ... LastLast
Results 21 to 30 of 110

Thread: Day 5...The Thief

  1. #21
    Pikeman
    Join Date
    09.12.2016
    Posts
    6

    Default

    The smith is a Teuton and tells the truth. "The potter is Gaul, of course, but you left your money in the carpenter's shop."

    The potter is a Gaul and tells lies "By the way, both the smith and the carpenter belong to the same tribe."

    The smith and the carpenter do not belong to the same tribe, and the smith is a Teuton.

    The carpenter is a Gaul and tells lies
    "Well, the potter tells the truth, but you left your money in his shop."

    The smith is a Teuton.
    The potter is a Gaul.
    The carpenter is a Gaul, and the money is in the carpenters shop.






    Rizla - Com3

  2. #22

    Default

    Emeradii, com1

    The smith is a Teuton
    The potter is a Gaul
    The carpenter is a Gaul, and is where Mark Atilius left his money

  3. #23
    Pikeman
    Join Date
    14.04.2009
    Location
    South Africa
    Posts
    19

    Default day 5 thief

    user dragon
    server ts19,travian.com

    left money in carpenter shop

  4. #24

    Default

    The smith is Teuton, the carpenter and the potter are Gauls. The smith tells the truth - the money are in the carpenter's shop.

    vandalooser

    RoA -ts19.travian.com

  5. #25

    Default

    Regarding the smith and the carpenter, as a pair, you have four possible scenarios:

    1. Both are teutons (i.e. telling the truth)
    2. Both are gaul (i.e. lying)
    3. The smith is gaul and the carpenter is teuton
    4. The smith is teuton and the carpenter is gaul

    If both are teutons, it means the smith is telling the truth, which means the potter would be gaul. That can't be the case, however, since that would mean that "the smith and the carpenter are in the same tribe" would be a lie, which violates 1. 1 is incorrect.

    If both are gaul, it means the carpenter's statement regarding the potter's truthfulness is a lie. However, for 2 to be the answer the potter's statement has to be true. 2 is therefore incorrect.

    If the smith is gaul it would mean the potter is teuton and is telling the truth about the smith and the carpenter being in the same tribe, which violates 3. 3 is incorrect also.

    If the smith is teuton it would mean that the potter is gaul and is lying about the same tribe statement. It would also mean that the carpenter is gaul (according to 4.) and that the carpenter's statement about the potter is false - and in this case we know from the truthful smith that the potter is gaul and is in fact lying. 4 is therefore correct.

    Ergo:
    The smith is teuton.
    The potter is gaul.
    The carpenter is gaul.

    And since the smith is teuton, we trust him when he tells us that the money is in the carpenter's shop.

    ANSWER: Money is in the carpenter's shop. The smith is teuton, the potter is gaul and the carpenter is gaul.


    Forgot to say my world and IGN: Lancemenot on speed3x!

  6. #26

    Default

    Smith is Teutons
    Potter is Gaul
    Carpenter is Gaul and money is here.
    Frodo
    Finals 2016

  7. #27

    Default

    smith -> potter is gaul, carpenter has money

    potter -> smith and carpenter are same tribe

    carpenter -> the potter tells truth, potter has money


    smith OR carpenter are lying

    therefore potter is lying - potter is Gaul


    smith tells truth - is Teuton, potter and carpenter are gauls and carpenter has the money

  8. #28
    Pikeman
    Join Date
    03.10.2016
    Posts
    16

    Default

    the smith : Teuton
    the potter : Gaul
    the carpenter : Gaul

    he left his money in the carpenter's shop

    ravsya
    com3

  9. #29

    Default

    Name: Avengers.
    Game world: Tournament finals

    answer: smith is teuton, potter is gaul, carpenter is gaul.
    Atilius left money at the carpenter's shop.

  10. #30
    Pikeman
    Join Date
    03.03.2017
    Posts
    2

    Default

    Smith is Teutons potter and carpenter are Gauls and the money is at carpenter's shop

    nick : cout
    server: tx3.travian.com

    Smith is Teuton
    Potter and Carpenter are Gauls

    Money is at carpenter's shop

    Smith is Teuton
    Potter and carpenter are Gauls

    Money is at the carpenter's shop

    nick: cout
    server: comx/tx3

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •